5.0 · 35 five-star Google reviews · Veteran-owned · Milford, Michigan · NMLS #23394
McKenney
Apply Online Get A Quote Refi Watchlist Call Rob: (248) 491-8998
← The McKenney Minute

The 1.72 million sellers nobody is calling.

The 1.72 million sellers nobody is calling — The McKenney Minute Issue #5

Short version: The Federal Housing Finance Agency estimates that mortgage lock-in prevented roughly 1.72 million home sales between mid-2022 and mid-2024 and pushed prices about 7% higher by choking off supply. What started as rate lock-in has quietly become life lock-in — people aren't stuck in a loan anymore, they're stuck in houses that no longer fit their lives. There's exactly one play that lets a homeowner move and keep the 3% rate, and most agents end the conversation before they ever get to it. Here's the read for your week.

📈THE 10-SECOND rate read

30-Year Fixed
6.65%
Up ~16 bps from Issue #4 baseline
10-Year Treasury
4.50%
Down 5 bps today; intraday low 4.47%

The holiday-shortened week ended with rates roughly unchanged. Today's move is fresh: mortgage bonds (the UMBS 6.0% coupon) are at 101.81, up 13 bps on US/Iran de-escalation chatter — the first meaningful rally in two weeks. MBS Highway's opening position is FLOATING: Dan's read is that there's room for rates to improve, but the peace-deal narrative is fragile. Treat today as a tactical window, not a confirmed trend, until two more sessions hold the gains.

This Week's Only Catalyst

Friday 8:30 AM ET — April Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) report. This is the Federal Reserve's preferred inflation gauge. Consensus is calling for 2.8% year-over-year core PCE. A hot print (above 2.8%) pushes rates higher into the weekend; a cool print (at or below) gives bonds room to rally and could finally crack the six-week ceiling we've been pinned under.

My take: Today's rally is real but built on a fragile narrative — peace-deal headlines can flip overnight. My desk is floating short positions this morning and watching the next 48 hours closely. Anyone closing inside 30 days locks before Friday's PCE — the asymmetry still favors locking. Anyone closing 30–90 days out floats with a tight trigger ready to pull if bonds give back the gains. Send me the buyer's closing date and I'll tell you the right window.

🏠THE MICHIGAN number

U.S. Home Sales Lost to Lock-In, Q2 2022 – Q2 2024
1.72 million
The Federal Housing Finance Agency estimates 1.72 million home sales didn't happen between mid-2022 and mid-2024 because of mortgage rate lock-in — and that the supply squeeze pushed home prices about 7% higher. That's 1.72 million listings that never hit the MLS. Anywhere.

What that means for Michigan: lock-in is a meaningful chunk of why your inventory feels thin even in submarkets where buyer demand is decent. Michigan homeowners who refinanced or purchased in 2020–2021 are sitting on rates between 2.5% and 3.5%. The math of giving that up to move feels brutal, so they don't list. They stay in homes that have outgrown their families, take jobs that require a punishing commute, or delay caring for an aging parent because the move "doesn't work financially."

The read-through for your week

The supply isn't gone — it's frozen in place. Every neighborhood you farm has homeowners who want to move and have quietly written it off.

What started as rate lock-in is now life lock-in. These owners aren't stuck in a loan; they're stuck in a house that no longer fits. That's a listing-strategy problem most agents still aren't running.

🔑THE ONE PLAY THAT KEEPS THE 3% rate

Most agents hear "I love my 3% rate" and treat it as a conversation-ender. There is exactly one way to move without giving up that rate. If anyone claims a bridge loan or buy-before-sell preserves it, they're wrong — the moment the current home sells, that mortgage gets paid off and the rate goes with it.

The only rate-keeper: keep the house, rent it out, buy the next one.
Fannie Mae lets a homeowner convert their primary to a rental and use the projected rent to qualify for the next purchase. With an executed lease, security deposit, and first month's rent received, 75% of gross rent counts toward qualifying income — usually enough to fully offset the old payment in the debt-to-income calculation. The 3% loan stays in place, the tenant pays it, and the homeowner qualifies for the next house at today's rate. The low-rate loan stops being a handcuff and becomes a passive-income asset.
Backup 1 — HELOC bridge for a smoother sale.
A HELOC on the current home funds the new down payment, so they buy first and sell on their own timeline instead of a contingent rush. The 3% loan pays off at sale closing — the rate is lost — but they never touched it during the transition. The benefit is friction reduction, not rate preservation.
Backup 2 — buy-before-sell bridge programs.
Non-QM bridge structures let the homeowner make a non-contingent offer using current home equity as collateral. Same end game as the HELOC — when the current home sells, the bridge pays off and the rate goes with it. The benefit is offer strength.

The honest line to use with the homeowner: if keeping the 3% rate is what matters most, the rental play is the only path that does it. Everything else trades the rate for something else — timing or offer strength. Don't let anyone pretend otherwise.

💬CLIENT text

Here's the text I'd send this week to every past client and sphere contact you suspect mentioned "wanting to move but loving the rate" sometime in the last 18 months:

📋 For your past-client list this week
"Hey [name] — random thought. I remember you mentioned [wanting more space / a different area / wanting to be closer to family] but didn't want to give up your rate. There's actually a way to keep the rate AND still move — you'd rent the current place out and the tenant covers the old payment. A few other options exist if renting isn't your thing, but the rental play is the only one that keeps the 3%. Worth a 10-minute call with my lender Rob to see what fits? No pressure either way — figured I'd flag it since it came up."

That text re-opens a conversation a lot of people had quietly written off. Forward me the name and a phone number after they reply and I'll handle the math conversation in fifteen minutes. You get the listing on the back end — and the move-up purchase.

💰DEAL-SAVER · keep the rate, become a landlord

Scenario: Homeowner has a $280,000 mortgage at 3.25% (P&I ~$1,220/mo). Current home would rent for ~$2,400/mo. They want to buy a $475,000 next home.

Component Number
Old mortgage P&IKept in place at 3.25% $1,220/mo
Projected rental income75% counts toward qualifying $1,800/mo
Net effect on debt-to-incomeAdded income, not a payment +$580/mo
Est. cash flow on old homeAfter taxes, insurance, maintenance reserve ~$300–500/mo
New home payment$475K, 10% down, ~6.50% PITI ~$3,150/mo

The bottom line: instead of dragging $1,220/mo of debt into qualifying, the homeowner walks in with $580/mo of added income. They keep the 3.25% loan, qualify at today's rate, and start a rental portfolio in the process.

The Pitch to Your Client

"You don't have to give up the 3% rate to move. You can keep it, rent the house out, and the tenant covers the old payment while you buy the new one. Rob can run the math on your specific numbers in about fifteen minutes."

Drop me an address, an estimated market rent, and the price range they're shopping and I'll build the full scenario — qualifying income, projected cash flow, total monthly outlay — co-branded with your name and number. 24-hour turnaround.

🎁FREE CO-BRANDED asset

The Lock-In Unlock One-Pager

A co-branded handout your sphere can actually use:

  • The rental play, in plain English
  • Your headshot, logo, and direct line
  • QR code to my calendar

Reply "Lock-In Unlock" with your headshot and brokerage logo. Print-ready PDF in your inbox by Wednesday.

Reply "Lock-In Unlock" →
The Closer
"Every neighborhood you farm has homeowners who want to move and have quietly written it off. The 3% rate doesn't have to be a life sentence — it's an asset they don't know how to use. The agents who learn to keep this conversation alive instead of ending it at 'they love their rate' are the ones quietly unlocking inventory nobody else is touching. Send me the name. We'll figure out whether the math works."
← Issue #4 All issues Issue #6 →

Want the Minute in your inbox?

If you're a Michigan realtor and this is useful, get it first thing Monday morning. No spam, no hype — just what moves the deal.

Text Rob